



I have no idea what the filmmakers were thinking when they decided we needed another adaptation of A Christmas Carol, because we most certainly did not. While I do have appreciation for it, I've never been a big fan of the story or its myriad of cinematic conversions. And they just keep on coming!
There are dozens of direct and loose film versions since the dawn of film itself, and I have seen far too many to count. Most do something creative, whether it's turning Scooge into a TV executive or have him haunted by puppets, but what about the latest interpretation "Ebenezer?" Well, it's the well-publicized comeback for star Johnny Depp. Suppose that's something to someone, somewhere. Probably.
The plot is blah, blah, blah, where blah is shown as blah and then blah happens, three times I might add, and then blah is transformed into a better blah. Got it? Good.
What's new this time around is its PG-13 rating, which allows director Ti West, famous for his numerous horror films, to seek out the macabre of the 1800's. The sets have this dark, dismal look to them, almost as if leftovers from an old Dracula picture, where ghost zombies stalk our antagonist-turned-protagonist as to keep him on-track towards his redemption. And yet, while so much effort was spent on the elaborate scenery, costumes and cast (which also includes Rupert Grint, Daisy Ridley and Ian McKellen, just to name a few), the heavy ghastliness of it all ends up being ugly. Handsomely ugly, of course, but ugly nonetheless. This is not a film I want to get lost in, to soak up the environment or to dream of living in. It is a warning of how bad things were, and if anything, it makes me appreciate having central heat.
A clever script would lay the obvious comparison between Ebenezer and star, whose success as a younger thespian lead to a swift downfall, only to be given a rare Hollywood second-chance. Alas, screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern does not take the chance. Sticking so aggressively to what's on the source material page by Charles Dickens, any freshness comes from West. He fills each frame with so much gothic misery that it chokes out any and all holiday cheer audiences expect from the genre.
But his talents feel restricted by its dedication to the original novel, like he wants so desperately to show buckets of icy blood but is stuck at the outer fringes of his usual genre. The atmosphere is a cold, depressing one where the mountains of clothing everyone wears look soaked in days' worth of sweat and dirt, their hands unkempt, both the poor and the rich. I am not one for labored saccharine messaging, mind you, but "the most wonderful time of the year" this ain't.
Depp is, I dunno, fine in the role; sometimes, buried beneath so much makeup and outfit, he was so far deep into character that I forgot who I was watching. Then he would jump on the bed and fall off in complete slapstick, and I would immediately be reminded. There isn't that much of his usual shtick honestly, for better or for worse, with only so many silly voices and with nary a drop of alcohol to be seen in hand or his lips. But then I recall the trailer for his next picture, which played before my showing, where he plays the title person in a film called "Day Drinker." Oh well.
No comments:
Post a Comment